Who we place with
Our carriers
Being independent means we answer to you rather than to one company. These are the carriers we place coverage with, and the numbers you need if you have to make a claim.
Erie Insurance
100 Erie Insurance Place
Erie, PA 16530-1104
Monday – Friday, 8:00a to 11:00p · Saturday, 9:00a to 4:30p
- Phone
- (888) 335-3743
Progressive
- Quotes — auto, motorcycle, boat, RV
- 1-800-776-4737
- Quotes — commercial auto and truck
- 1-888-806-9598
- Customer service
- 1-800-776-4737
- Claims
- 1-800-776-4737
- Claims grievance
- 1-800-274-4641
The Hanover
24-hour claim service
- Claim service hotline
- 800-628-0250
- Platinum claim service
- 800-799-6977
- Fax
- 800-399-4734
Hagerty
Hagerty Insurance Agency, LLC
P.O. Box 1303
Traverse City, MI 49685-1303
- Auto
- 877-922-9701
- Claims
- 800-922-4050
- Fax
- 231-941-8227
- Quotes and policy questions
- auto@hagerty.com
- Claims
- claims@hagerty.com
- Send photos
- photo@hagerty.com
Madison Mutual Illinois
1 Mutual Court
Post Office Box 129
Edwardsville, IL 62025-0129
- Phone
- 618-656-3410
- Toll free
- 800-766-6642
Proud member of Trusted Choice
Trusted Choice is a network of independent insurance agents — not a carrier. Membership commits us to presenting you with options rather than a single company's product.